Firing an Employee: When to Coach and When to Call It Quits

In the intricate lives of managers, few tasks prove as challenging and emotionally taxing as firing an employee. While managers take on many roles, their primary responsibility remains to ensure optimal team performance and alignment with company objectives. This often means deciphering between two critical junctures: coaching an employee towards improvement or making the difficult termination decision.

Understanding the nuances of when to coach and when to consider firing an employee is pivotal. The impact of these decisions resonates with the employee in question and the entire team, organizational culture, and bottom line. This article aims to guide managers through this intricate process, offering insights and strategies to approach such challenging decisions with clarity and confidence.

Understanding the Importance of Employee Coaching

For most managers, firing an employee is a last resort, underscoring the invaluable role of coaching. Before resorting to such a definitive action, it’s essential to recognize the transformative power that coaching holds.


When managers invest time in coaching, they address performance issues and send a strong message about their to employee success. This commitment can significantly reduce the need for firing an employee by addressing and rectifying issues before they escalate.

Consider this: An employee’s performance might wane not out of sheer negligence or indifference but perhaps due to knowledge gaps, lack of understanding of their role, or personal challenges they’re navigating. In such cases, firing an employee might be premature and detrimental to the organization’s reputation and morale.

Effective coaching bridges these gaps, allowing employees to course-correct, upskill, and re-align with organizational objectives. Moreover, a well-coached employee often becomes an ambassador for growth within the team, creating a ripple effect of increased productivity and engagement.


However, it’s equally crucial to discern when coaching is optimal and when the situation necessitates considering termination. As we dive deeper into this guide, we’ll explore these distinctions, ensuring managers are equipped to make informed decisions in the best interests of both the employee and the organization.

Identifying When to Coach: Examples of Coachable Moments

Navigating the crossroads of coaching versus firing an employee requires a keen understanding of what constitutes a “coachable moment.” Recognizing these moments can be the crucial difference between fostering an environment of growth and prematurely severing salvageable employees.

Lack of Knowledge or Understanding:

Imagine an employee with frequent errors in their tasks, not out of disinterest but due to genuine gaps in their understanding. Instead of immediately firing such an employee, this presents an opportune moment to coach them. They may need a refresher course, more hands-on training, or clearer instructions.


Transition-Related Performance Gaps:

An employee who once excelled in their previous role might now falter after a recent transition or promotion. Their current struggles might not reflect their overall capability but rather their adaptation phase to the new role’s demands. Again, before considering firing an employee, managers should identify this as a coachable moment to provide support and training during their transition.

Demonstrated Willingness to Learn:

The attitude of an employee plays a significant role in determining coachability. If employees acknowledge their mistakes, seek feedback, and showcase a genuine desire to improve, it’s a clear sign that they are open to coaching. Firing an employee in such circumstances without offering adequate coaching might lead to losing talent who merely needed guidance.

However, while many scenarios can be addressed through coaching, there are moments when termination might be necessary. As we delve further into this guide, we’ll outline how to make these distinctions, ensuring that the decision to coach or contemplate firing an employee is well-informed and justifiable.


Skill vs. Will: Distinguishing the Root Cause of Performance Issues

Before jumping to the conclusion of firing an employee due to underperformance, managers must pinpoint the underlying cause. Performance issues can typically be bucketed into two categories: those arising from a lack of skill and those stemming from a lack of will. Distinguishing between the two can guide managers on the right course of action.

The Skill Deficit:

Sometimes, employees struggle simply because they lack the necessary skills or knowledge.

Example: A seasoned salesperson might struggle with a new CRM tool. Their issue isn’t an inherent inability to perform their job but a specific skill gap in utilizing the software. Rather than firing an employee in such situations, offering additional training or resources can be the solution.


The Will Deficit:

Contrarily, there are instances where an employee possesses all the necessary skills but lacks motivation, commitment, or the right attitude.

Example: An employee, fully trained in company protocols, consistently turns in reports late or avoids team collaborations. The issue here isn’t their capability but their will to deliver.

Determining the cause between skill and will is pivotal. Coaching, mentoring, and training are typically effective remedies for skill-related concerns. These employees often show a marked improvement once the necessary support is provided, making the thought of firing them a premature action.


However, the challenge becomes more nuanced when it comes to will deficits. While managers can address some motivational issues through coaching, chronic lack of motivation or repeated disregard for company standards might warrant more serious considerations, including the potential of firing an employee.

The key lies in continuous observation, feedback, and communication as managers navigate these intricacies. The objective is to ensure that the decision—coaching or considering termination—is based on a comprehensive understanding of the root cause and not just surface-level symptoms.

When to Fire an Employee: Recognizing the Signs

Terminating an employee is one of the manager’s most challenging responsibilities. It carries emotional, organizational, and sometimes legal implications. Yet, there are circumstances when termination becomes the necessary course of action. Recognizing the signs that lead to this conclusion is critical for a team or organization’s overall health and productivity.


Chronic Underperformance Despite Multiple Interventions:

If an employee continues to underperform, even after providing numerous coaching sessions, training, and resources, it might be time to reconsider their role in the organization. Continual non-performance can strain team dynamics and become detrimental to overall productivity.

Clear Misalignment with Company Values:

Every organization operates on a set of core values. It raises concerns if an employee repeatedly violates these values or exhibits behaviors at odds with the company culture. For example, an organization prioritizing teamwork and collaboration will find it challenging to retain an employee who consistently undermines colleagues or refuses to work cohesively.

Repeated Policy Violations:

Company policies exist for a reason – they ensure smooth operations, compliance, and a safe working environment. Despite warnings and clarifications, an employee who repeatedly breaches these policies becomes a liability. In such cases, the thought of firing an employee gains ground not just for performance but for the security and integrity of the entire organization.


Negative Impact on Team Morale:

One persistently disruptive employee can cast a shadow over the entire team. Whether it’s through negativity, toxic behaviors, or consistently poor work ethic, their actions can diminish morale and affect the motivation of other team members. While coaching should be the first response, termination might become the unavoidable next step if the behavior continues unabated.

Concluding this section, it’s crucial to approach the process of firing an employee with a blend of empathy, clarity, and decisiveness. Keeping the organization’s best interests at heart while ensuring fairness and respect towards the employee in question will ensure the process, though tough, is carried out professionally and humanely.

Why Making Firing Decisions Quickly is Crucial

One of the most testing decisions for a manager revolves around firing an employee. While patience, coaching, and guidance are valuable tools, there comes a point when prolonging a termination decision can be detrimental. Recognizing why swift decisions in these situations are crucial is essential for any leader aiming to maintain organizational health and efficiency.


Protecting Team Morale and Productivity:

Every day that a consistently underperforming or disruptive employee remains on the team can erode morale and hinder productivity. Other team members might feel they’re shouldering an unfair burden or become demotivated, seeing that lack of performance or disruptive behavior isn’t being addressed. Managers can protect the team’s spirit and maintain a positive working environment by making swift decisions about firing an employee.

Financial Implications:

An underperforming employee can have direct financial consequences. Whether it’s through mistakes, inefficiencies, or simply the cost of repeated training and interventions, delays in addressing these issues can be costly. Firing an employee when necessary, though challenging, can prevent these escalating costs.

Reputation Management:

In the age of workplace reviews and open communication, having a problematic employee can impact an organization’s internal and external reputation. Potential hires might think twice about joining a company that needs to address evident issues or one that has persistent negative reviews from previous employees.


Opportunity Cost:

Delaying the decision to fire an employee can also mean delaying the opportunity to bring in fresh talent. A new hire can introduce innovative ideas, improved skills, and a boost in team energy – all potentially missed out on if a termination decision is unduly postponed.

Clarity and Direction:

Decisive actions, even the tough ones, set a precedent. They communicate that the organization values performance, integrity, and the team’s overall health. Managers can foster a culture of accountability and direction by swiftly addressing the need to fire an employee when warranted.

In conclusion, while firing an employee is never pleasant, the timeliness of this decision is paramount. Balancing empathy with the larger organizational picture ensures that such decisions, when needed, are made with both heart and foresight.


How to Conduct an Effective Coaching Conversation

Entering into a coaching conversation, especially with the looming possibility of firing an employee, demands tact, preparation, and genuine intent. The aim should always be growth and improvement, with termination as a final option if coaching doesn’t yield positive changes. Here’s a guide to ensure the conversation is as effective as possible:

Set Clear Expectations:

Before diving into the conversation, outline its objectives. Clearly communicate the intention behind this talk, ensuring the employee understands this is a coaching session aimed at their growth, even if the backdrop may be performance concerns that could lead to firing.

Use the SBI (Situation, Behavior, Impact) Feedback Model:

This model offers a structured way to deliver feedback:

  • Situation: Describe the specific event or instance where you noticed the problematic behavior.
  • Behavior: Outline the exact behavior or actions that were concerning.
  • Impact: Share how this behavior impacted the team, project, or organization.

Example: “During last week’s team presentation (Situation), I observed that you didn’t contribute any updates on your segment (Behavior). This left the team without vital information and affected the overall flow of the meeting (Impact).”

Listen Actively:

Coaching isn’t just about pointing out flaws. It’s a two-way street. Allow the employee to share their perspective. Maybe they have challenges you need to be aware of, or perhaps they need to understand the gravity of their actions.

Avoid Making It Personal:

Even if the conversation is a precursor to potentially firing an employee, ensure it remains professional. Stick to facts, observations, and avoid statements that attack the person instead of addressing the behavior.


Craft a Development Plan Together:

Empower the employee by involving them in creating a roadmap to improvement. This could include additional training, regular check-ins, or setting specific performance milestones.

Clarify Consequences:

While the focus is on coaching, it’s essential to be transparent about potential consequences if there isn’t an improvement. Phrase it constructively, ensuring the employee understands that the ultimate aim is growth, but continuous underperformance could lead to considerations of firing.

Schedule Follow-Up Check-ins:

More than one conversation is needed. Regular follow-ups allow the manager and the employee to track progress, address ongoing challenges, and modify the development plan if required.


In summary, while the prospect of firing an employee can loom over a coaching conversation, the central goal should always be the development and betterment of the individual. Managers can often turn potential termination scenarios into success stories by approaching them with understanding, clarity, and a focus on growth.

The Art of the Termination Conversation

No manager aspires to have this conversation, but sometimes, despite best efforts, firing an employee becomes necessary. The termination conversation is sensitive, demanding adherence to legal and company guidelines and a considerable degree of empathy and tact. Here’s a structured approach to ensure the process is both professional and compassionate:

Be Prepared:

Before initiating the conversation, ensure you’re equipped with all the documentation and performance records that led to this decision. This preparation will help clarify the reasons for firing an employee and address any questions or concerns.


Choose an Appropriate Setting:

The conversation should be held privately, ideally in a neutral setting where both parties feel at ease. The environment should be free from interruptions, ensuring the employee feels respected.

Be Direct but Compassionate:

While it’s crucial to be straightforward about the decision, approach the topic sensitively. Begin with a statement that gets straight to the point, but ensure it’s delivered with empathy.

Example: “I want to let you know that after considerable evaluation and attempts at coaching, we’ve made the difficult decision to end your employment with the company.”


Provide Clear Reasons:

Refer back to previous discussions, performance reviews, and coaching sessions. The employee must understand that firing wasn’t a hasty decision but one reached after multiple interventions and considerations.

Listen Actively:

The employee might have questions, concerns, or even emotions to express. While the decision remains unchanged, allowing them a chance to speak is a mark of respect and understanding.

Discuss the Logistics:

Outline the practical aspects of the termination, including final paycheck details, benefits, and any potential references or outplacement services. The employee should leave the conversation with a clear understanding of the next steps.


Offer Support:

Whether through references, counseling, or job placement assistance, discuss how the company can support the employee in their transition.

Close with Dignity:

Conclude the conversation with gratitude for their contributions and wish them well in their future endeavors. Remember, how an employee is let go can significantly influence their perception of the company and their experiences.

Terminating an employee is never easy, but when approached with preparation, clarity, and compassion, it can be done with dignity and respect. The goal should always be to ensure that even in parting ways, the company and the employee move forward with closure and understanding.


Navigating the complexities of employee management, especially when coaching or firing an employee, is undeniably one of the toughest tasks a manager faces. Balancing the organization’s needs with an individual’s professional and personal growth requires tact, understanding, and a steadfast commitment to fairness.

However, as challenging as these situations are, they offer invaluable learning experiences. Whether through effective coaching that turns an underperforming employee into a star performer. Or, with the tough but necessary action of termination, managers can shape their teams’ culture, productivity, and overall health.

If you find yourself grappling with these decisions or need advice on the nuances of managing team dynamics, remember you’re not alone. The “Ask a Coach” section is at your disposal. Reach out for guidance, insights, or even a sounding board as you navigate the challenging waters of coaching and firing an employee. Your dedication to effective and compassionate leadership can make all the difference, and having the right resources and support at hand can elevate your managerial journey.


Get the Weekly Roundup

Join thousands of other career-minded people who receive early access to my career-changing articles.

Jason Cortel is currently the Director of Global Workforce Management for a leading technology company. He has been in customer service, marketing, and sales services for over 20 years. In addition, he has extensive experience in offshore and nearshore outsourcing. Jason is an avid Star Trek fan and is on a mission to change the universe by helping people develop professionally. He is driven to help managers and leaders lead their teams better. Jason is also a veteran in creating talent and office cultures.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Need advice or help with your boss? Click to Learn More.